Europe’s right turn on refugee policy: a moral and strategic mistake

European democracies are under threat from the rise of the far right, fueled partly by anti-refugee backlash. In response, mainstream political parties often employ a strategy of accommodation: they adopt the anti-refugee policies and rhetoric of the far right to win back voters. In this blog post we argue that accommodation is a strategic and moral mistake: the research shows that its success is unlikely, whereas it involves serious moral costs.

Far-right parties are ascendant across Europe. Their popularity is due in part to their open hostility towards refugees and their extreme positions on migration. In the face of mounting electoral pressure, center-right and center-left parties throughout Europe have shifted rightward on migration and refugee policy. Political scientists call the strategy of shifting one’s issue to converge with that of a challenge party is the “accommodative strategy” in contrast to (e.g.) the “adversarial strategy” of highlighting the policy difference. In this blog post, we explore the strategic and moral costs associated with this strategy. We argue that these costs aren’t usually worth the alleged benefits.

 

Accommodation in Practice

It may be helpful to start with a few examples. One of the clearest examples of the accommodative strategy is Denmark, where the Danish Social Democrats seemed to dampen the far-right’s advance via (e.g.) a discriminatory ghetto law and a bilateral agreement to offshore asylum-seekers to Rwanda (although the agreement with never put into practice).

Since then, the accommodative strategy has spread throughout Europe. In a move directly inspired by the Danish model, beleaguered former British Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s Labour government embraced anti-refugee policies, signing a “one in, one out” deal with France and attempting to bar refugees accessing citizenship for decades. “We need to reduce immigration significantly” lest Britain become an “island of strangers,” he proclaimed in a public address.

So too with Germany. Under Friedrich Merz, the CDU has shifted dramatically to the right on refugees, cracking the firewall (Brandmauer) by relying on AfD votes to pass a resolution sanctioning more restrictions on border crossings. Playing on racial tropes, he framed migrants as “problems in the cityscape” and has pitched the expansion of the use of third-country “return hubs,” which many fear are ‘human rights black holes’.

During his tenure, ex-chancellor Olaf Scholz promised an aggressive deportation campaign (“wir müssen endlich im großen Stil abschieben”, he claimed in an interview), introduced a constraining debit card program (Bezahlkarte) to regulate benefits to asylum applications, and supported inhumane reforms to the Common European Asylum System (CEAS). These reforms included the introduction of fast-track “border procedures” to assess asylum claims, which impede access to asylum and limit applications access to procedural protections, the expansion of the use of detention – often, in appalling conditions – for irregular entrants, and the normalization of removal to ‘safe third countries’, including the lowering of the threshold for proving that a country is “safe.”

These sorts of policies make it more difficult for refugees to access international protection by making the denial of asylum claims and deportation easier. They make the lives of refugees and asylum seekers more precarious and the protection they receive less dignified and more temporary. They imperil the legal rights of refugees and asylum-seekers.

Despite these worries, these measures are defended by their proponents as necessary. The rationale for accommodation is that, by shifting right, mainstream parties can win back voters who have defected to far-right parties like Reform UK and the AfD. Since keeping these parties out of power is crucially important for preserving democracy, if accommodation is necessary for that purpose, it may seem a tolerable, even obligatory, political compromise.

Yet, there are two important questions political strategists and the European public should ask about this strategy. First, is accommodation in the domain of refugee policy effective? That is, is shifting right on refugee policy by the established parties likely to keep the far-right out of power? Second, is accommodation worth the moral (and material) costs – not only to refugees and migrants, but also to the broader democratic cultures of the states in which it is pursued? We argue that the answer is ‘no’ on both counts. Accommodating the far-right by adopting a more restrictive stance on asylum is not only likely to backfire; it risks producing grave harms to refugees and to societies more broadly that are not worth the (uncertain) benefits.  Our post thus contributes to the wider public debate about how to respond strategically to the radical right by not only integrating a wide body of empirical research but also by drawing attention to the broader moral costs associated with pursuing the accommodative strategy.

 

Does Accommodation Work?

The first problem with the accommodative strategy is that it is unlikely to succeed. Whether the accommodative strategy works is an empirical question, which political scientists have studied in detail. The overall balance of evidence does not support accommodation. One study, analyzing party manifestos and electoral outcomes from Denmark, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the United Kingdom, finds that left-wing parties (but not center-right parties) benefit in aggregate from rightward shifts by a mainstream party on immigration in a multiparty system. The shift attracts anti-immigration voters while repelling pro-immigration voters; since the new voters come from the right and the repelled voters defect to other left parties with pro-immigration stances, the result is a net increase in support for the left. Another study, analyzing data from 28 Western European countries, suggests that adopting a hardline stance is successful, but only when combined with a cordon sanitaire (i.e., a strategy of electoral non-cooperation).

The strongest evidence for accommodation generally comes from Denmark. But advocates of the ‘Danish model’ of embracing far-right migration politics overstate the quality of this evidence. For one, Denmark hasn’t halted the rise of the far-right; the far-right has recently been polling as strong as ever. For another, the Danish Social Democrats may be floundering. The party recently lost an election in Copenhagen for the first time in over a century. Finally, researchsuggests that the past success of the Danish Social Democrats is explained in large part by a left turn on welfare, not a right turn on migration.

Moreover, the evidence in favor of accommodation is greatly outweighed by the evidence against it. The largest studyto date on the success of accommodation, which examines 350 mainstream party strategies in over 100 electoral contexts, finds no support for the claim that accommodating weakens the radical right electorally. Instead, it finds that the radical right net benefits from accommodation. Voters defect from accommodative mainstream parties to the far-right “in remarkable numbers.” The authors conclude that accommodation is “fruitless in the best case, and can be detrimental in the worst case.”

A recent study illustrates this clearly. Voters in the study were randomly exposed to Keir Starmer’s May 12, 2025 “Island of Strangers” speech, in which Starmer’s outlined a new hardline agenda. The speech marked a significant rhetorical shift rightwards on immigration, one frequently compared to Enoch Powell’s infamous 1968 ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech. The study finds that voters exposed to the speech were less likely to support Labour post-exposure. Support for Reform, in contrast, remained unchanged. This fits other findings that Labour has, thus far, won over zero percent of those who voted Reform in the last election. His recent thrashing in local elections is even more evidence that accommodation is a strategic mistake. While a multitude of factors explain this electoral outcome, Labour’s rightward shift has undoubtedly not helped stop the rise of Reform.

The political science literature on strategies of party competition in Europe suggests three reasons why accommodation fails. First, accommodation alienates some mainstream voters. Second, accommodation affords far-right positions on immigration legitimacy and credibility. This makes far-right parties appear more competent. Third, since anti-immigrant attitudes are stable, the far right succeeds mainly by making immigration salient, galvanizing these preexisting anti-immigrant attitudes. But accommodation further “increases the salience of immigration, emphasizing the very issue that drives the far right’s electoral success”. This undermines efforts to demobilize right-wing voters, which require reducing immigration’s salience. Thus, as long as immigration remains salient, the far-right will win out, as they are the most trusted ‘brand’ of anti-refugee politics.

 

Is Accommodation Worth the Costs?

So far, we argued that the balance of evidence suggests that accommodation doesn’t work. But let us assume, for the sake of argument, that it does work. After all, who knows, perhaps in the long run it will prove more effective than we thought. If accommodation did work, should we use it? Note that even if accommodation works, it comes at a cost. Indeed, it has myriad social and moral costs which, in our view, greatly outweigh the benefits it brings. We highlight two such costs: the material harm accommodation inflicts on refugees and asylum seekers, and the broader negative impact of accommodation on the social standing of both migrants and citizens of immigrant descent.

First, as we illustrate below, accommodative policies often impose serious material harms and even jeopardize the basic human rights of refugees. This is because accommodative policies typically involve doubling down on forms of migration control that violate the rights of refugees and result in serious harms.

Consider the Polish example. After his electoral victory, centrist Donald Tusk indicated that his administration would retain the (unconstitutional) rules on pushbacks first introduced by Law and Justice (PiS). These rules have enabled the Polish border guards to brutally refoul asylum-seekers to Belarus, using excessive force. This has caused dozens of deaths at the Polish-Belarus border. Indeed, Tusk’s government passed a bill allowing soldiers to “preventatively” fire “live ammunition” at migrants without criminal liability. This example is extreme, but many of the policies adopted by European states in recent years – from third-country cooperation agreements to the recent CEAS reform – involve similar harms to refugees: they violate people’s rights against arbitrary detention, increase the risk of refoulement, and expand the use of encampment, and sometimes involve paying foreign states like Libya to imprison migrants. We cannot justify actively harming people for the sake of preserving “our” democracy. But this is what many accommodative policies, in fact, do.

Second, the accommodative strategy, to be successful, must involve measures that publicly signal that mainstream political actors are willing to cater to the preferences of backlashers and get ‘tough on’ refugees and other ‘undesirable’ migrants. Think of Merz’s ‘cityscape’ remarks and Starmer’s promises to ‘take back control’ and stop ‘chaos’ migration. Political science research shows that mainstream politicians throughout Europe have embraced far-right rhetoric on migration. To succeed in taking ownership over the migration issue, politicians must express their willingness to target refugees for specifically disadvantageous treatment. This inevitably marks refugees as bearers of a distinct, inferior social status, and framing them as inherently threatening and irredeemably unassimilable.

This produces broader societal harms. By normalizing and mainstreaming the far right’s talking points, accommodation contributes to the erosion of norms against xenophobic speech and action. Consider the 2024 anti-Muslim and anti-refugee riots in the UK, which followed a marked shift to the right on immigration by the Conservative Party and the Labor Party under Keir Starmer. These events were no accident, but the result of a society that tolerates and publicly endorses anti-migrant animus. The erosion of such norms puts not only refugees, but persons with migration backgrounds at risk.

The broader point is that restrictive policies designed to cater backslash express a view of certain migrants and refugees as a population to be “tough on.” This alters how refugees, other migrants, and citizens are perceived, often on account of their racial or religious identities. Migrants deserve to have their moral equality and dignity respected, and those granted residence or citizenship need to be treated as equal members of society. Accommodation promotes norms and attitudes that are incompatible with this basic moral demand.

 

“But Democracy Must Be Preserved!”

The strongest justification of the accommodative strategy is that it is necessary to preserve democracy by keeping the far-right out of power. While we agree that keeping the far-right out of power is of critical importance, we think this argument misunderstands the nature and value of democracy. Democracy, properly understood, is more than just a system of institutions. Rather, a democratic order is one that is based on certain core democratic values, such as equality, freedom, and respect for human rights.

This gives us reason to doubt about the quality of democracy that can be preserved through means that are, ultimately, incompatible with democratic values – specifically, the value of social equality. By ‘social equality,’ we mean – following a long tradition of philosophical work – the ability of individuals in a society to relate to one another as peers with equal social standing, rather than as superiors and inferiors in an ongoing social hierarchy. Accommodative strategies tend to use precisely such anti-democratic means. They impair the equal dignity of immigrants and citizens of immigrant background.

This occurs in a variety of different ways. First, consider how accommodative policies target citizens of immigrant background. Take the example of Denmark’s infamous ghetto law, which discriminatorily targets neighborhoods with a high percentage of residents with ‘non-Western’ migration backgrounds. One young Danish citizen of Afghani descent, Amina Safi, stated her critique of the law as follows, “The ghetto list stigmatizes us. We feel like second-class citizens. Tingbjerg is such a great area, but we constantly have to defend ourselves because of our address.” A society cannot be said to rest on a genuine commitment to the value of social equality if it subjects those who are perceived “outsiders” to systematic discrimination on the basis of morally arbitrary factors, such as ethnic and religious identities.

To this, defenders of accommodation might reply that securing democratic equality for insiders must be procured at the price of subordination of outsiders, given the (regrettable) fact of nativism among many electorates. Note, first, that this is not even true. Anti-migrant rhetoric has spillover effects that undermine the equal citizenship of citizens perceived as racially other. But, second, we need to recognize that “democracy” purchased at this price is hardly worth the name. Is a system that grants equality, freedom, and rights to some (namely those who are seen as belonging to the native white majority), but is kept in place through the continual subordination, stigmatization, and exclusion of an already vulnerable group a true democracy? In our view, the answer is no. By preserving the equality and democratic rights of a specific dominant group through the systematic exclusion and oppression of vulnerable outsiders, accommodation undermines those exact democratic values it aims to preserve. This, in our view, is a hitherto unappreciated moral cost of the accommodative strategy that, like the previous ones, is almost certain to occur once the strategy is adopted.

 

A Way Forward

But what should mainstream parties do instead? We don’t claim to have a silver-bullet solution. There are dilemmas and trade-offs that democratically-minded parties need to grapple with in responding to far-right populism. Likely, there is no one-sized-fits-all solution that will work for every context. Yet, it is important to note that there are alternatives available.

Parties can foreground other issues. Issues such as inflation, housing, and economic inequality are familiar examples, which parties might campaign on to win back voters attracted to the radical right. While the data here is limited, some evidence suggests that targeted wedge campaigns may be successful. Because migration is so salient, mainstream parties do need to take a stance. But they might instead downplay migration issue, seeking to diminish its salience.

Alternatively, politicians can reframe the migration issue and embrace more pro-migration stances, adopting a more “adversarial” strategy. Green parties have pursued this to some avail. Not everyone hates refugees. And some political scientists posit a “reverse backlash” effect: the rise of far-right parties has led to an increase in positive attitudes towards immigration by certain segments of the population. Parties can harness this effect. These strategies may fare at least as well as accommodation in many contexts, without incurring the grave moral costs we identified above. While some evidence points in this direction – and lots of evidence, as we note above, speaks against the effectiveness of the accommodative strategy, these alternative strategies need to be studied in more detail.

There may be reasonable strategic and moral disagreement about how to respond to migration backlash and how to keep the far-right out of power. And there are limits on how successfully politicians can pitch pro-refugee policies to skeptical publics. But embracing the far-right’s own policies towards refugees is not the cure for democracies ills that political leaders and strategists make it out to be. It is likely to undermine, rather than preserve, democracy.

Share this post

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
XING
Email
Print

Subscribe to our free RSS feed: